SHOULD CHRISTIANS PARTICIPATE IN POLITICS?
Many who profess to be Christians strongly believe that it is their duty to be involved in politics for the good of this world. There is no doubt that many of these Christians are very sincere and well-meaning in their efforts. Should Christians participate in politics?
“If I had to do it all over again, I would avoid any semblance of involvement in partisan politics . . . An evangelist is called to do one thing, and one thing only: to proclaim the gospel.”—Billy Graham, during an interview in the later years of his life
This is quite an admission for one of the most famous Christian preachers, who had spent time with many prominent people of the world, including 12 US Presidents. (See the article on this website entitled, “Learn One Thing From Billy Graham’s Life Confession”). This should at least give us pause when considering our own decision of whether to be involved in “partisan politics. Billy Graham referred to the one thing a Christian is “called to do,” and that is what Jesus commanded: “Go and make disciples of all peoples” (Matthew 28:19 NLT margin). He also referred to a Christian’s need for singleness of focus on spreading the gospel, which can be illustrated this way: ““Bear your share of difficulties, like a good soldier of Christ Jesus. No one on active service involves himself in the affairs of of civilian life, because he must win the approval of the man who enlisted him” (2 Timothy 2:3,4 NJB). Another Bible principle can also be applied here: “Jesus said, ‘No one who sets a hand to the plough and looks to what was left behind is fit for the kingdom of God” (Luke 9:62 NAB). To plow straight furrows in a field, one must keep focused on what is ahead, not behind. Political involvement could, at a minimum, cause a Christian to lose his/her focus on spreading the gospel.
For Christians, “All scripture is inspired by God and useful for refuting error, for guiding people’s lives and teaching them to be his people. This is how someone who is dedicated to God becomes fully equipped and ready for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16,17 NJB). Is it possible that Christian involvement in politics could be included as a type of “error” referred to in the scriptures? While there are no examples in the Bible of God’s people being involved in politics, there is no specific counsel to the contrary in the Bible either. Therefore, we do well to consider what Bible principles may apply in such a situation, and make decisions based on those Bible principles. Are there any Bible principles that indicate that God may not want his people to be involved in partisan politics?
Some Christians believe that it their duty to try to elect good people to political office so as to improve the world, and also to help facilitate the spread of the gospel. However, Jesus’ direction to his followers seems to run counter to that idea: “Seek the Kingdom of God above all else and live righteously, and he will give you everything you need” (Matthew 6:33 NLT).
There is nothing wrong with government employment. However, government employment is not the same thing as political involvement. God’s people have worked for governments since ancient times. Examples of pre-Christians are Joseph, Mordecai, Nehemiah and Daniel, Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego (Genesis 41:41-43; Nehemiah 2:1; Esther 10:3; Daniel 2:48,49). Paul, apparently writing from the city of Corinth, concludes the book of Romans with greetings from some early Christians. “Erastus, the city treasurer, and our brother Quartus greet you” (Romans 16:23 NAB). Erastus was a Christian who was employed as “the city treasurer.”
The Bible tells us that, “Everyone must submit to governing authorities. For all authority comes from God, and those placed in positions of authority have been placed there by God” (Romans 13:1 NLT). The point here is that “all authority comes from God,” and “those placed in positions of authority have been placed there by God,” not humans. There is no indication here, or elsewhere in the Bible, that God wants us to help select those “placed in positions of authority” by him.
The book of Daniel makes clear that “the Most High God rules over the kingdoms of this world and appoints anyone he wishes to rule over them,” and “he controls the course of world events; he removes kings and sets up kings” (Daniel 5:21; 2:21 NLT). The Bible also tells us that, “From one man he created all the nations throughout the whole earth. He decided beforehand when they should rise and fall, and he determined their boundaries” (Acts 17:26 NLT). Since he “has perfect knowledge” (Job 36:4 NIV), and is “Almighty” (Job 37:23), we can trust his decisions and judgments to always be perfectly right. Since “God controls the course of world events,” and has ‘decided in advance when nations and leaders should rise and fall,’ there is really nothing we can do to change that.
These Bible principles certainly do not mean that those in political power always do the right things. They don’t. The governments are run by sinful people, (Romans 3:23), who make mistakes, and some are even “corrupt” (Psalm 14:1 NIV). “Satan, the ruler of this world” (John 12:31 NLT) is shown in the Bible to have much influence over the governments of the world. When he “showed [Jesus] all the kingdoms of the world” and said, “all this power . . . has been handed over to me, and I may give it to whomever I wish” (Luke 4:5,6 NAB), Jesus did not contradict his claim, but he flatly rejected Satan’s suggestion to worship him in exchange for rulership over them. Keeping these facts and principles in mind will help us to realize that we will not be able to change this world.
Jesus said that his disciples “do not belong to the world any more than I belong to the world” (John 17:14,16 NAB, NJB). Jesus further emphasized this principle by saying, “The world would love you as its own if you belonged to it, but you are no longer part of the world. I chose you to come out of the world, so it hates you” (John 15:19 NLT). Christians are told that, “Religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father is this: . . . to keep oneself unstained by the world” (James 1:27 NAB). These directives, combined with other Biblical statements, can be seen as Christians being advised to avoid partisan politics. Political neutrality is another way to express such an idea.
Did Jesus ever involve himself in any politics of this world? No, he didn’t! “When the people saw the sign he had done [miraculously feeding thousands], they said, ‘This is truly the Prophet, the one who is to come into the world.’ Since Jesus knew that they were going to come and carry him off to make him king, he withdrew into the mountain alone” (John 6:14,15 NAB). He refused to be drafted into politics as a leader. The Bible tells us that “Christ . . . left an example for you to follow in his steps” (1 Peter 2:21 NJB). If the greatest man who ever lived avoided political involvement, perhaps we should too.
Did Jesus ever make any political comments, or give any political opinions? No! He was asked, “Is it permissible to pay taxes to Caesar or not? . . . Jesus . . . replied, ‘. . . Show me the money you pay the tax with.’ They handed him a denarius, and he said, ‘Choose portrait is this? Whose title?’ They replied, ‘Caesar’s.’ Then he said to them, ‘Very well, pay Caesar what belongs to Caesar–and God what belongs to God'” (Matthew 22:17-21 NJB). Jesus did not express any opinion one way or the other about paying taxes to the Roman government, other than to say, ‘If you owe the tax, pay it.’
Did the early Christians involve themselves in any politics of their day? No! So, because of this, they were viewed with suspicion. For example, it was said of them, “They are all guilty of treason against Caesar, for they profess allegiance to another king, named Jesus” (Acts 17:17 NLT). Paul, Silas and other Christians were not advocating rebellion against the Roman government, but their loyalty to another king sounded suspicious. Early Christians were known for their non-involvement in politics. Strict application of Bible principles by Christians today often results in misunderstandings.
Another aspect to consider is that all nations are eventually doomed to destruction from God. “All the kings of the earth and their armies” will be “gathered together to fight” against Jesus “and his army” during “the war of the Great Day of God the Almighty” (Revelation 16:14; 19:19-21 NJB). Why put forth so much effort into something that God is going to destroy?
Sometimes people misunderstand those Christians who are politically neutral, and they think that their message is to get everyone in the world to stay out of politics. They raise objections, such as: ‘If everyone avoided politics, who will run the world?’ We can learn a lesson from Jesus’ statement concerning a different issue: “Jesus told him, ‘Let the spiritually dead bury their own dead! Your duty is go and preach about the kingdom of God'” (Luke 9:60 NLT). One point we can glean from this is that there will always be plenty of people who will ‘run the world’ by being in political power.
3 thoughts on “SHOULD CHRISTIANS PARTICIPATE IN POLITICS?”
BA: Many who profess to be Christians strongly believe that it is their duty to be involved in politics for the good of this world. There is no doubt that many of these Christians are very sincere and well-meaning in their efforts.
GW: It is the duty of all citizens to be involved in politics for the good of this world, and Christians are no exception.
BA: “If I had to do it all over again, I would avoid any semblance of involvement in partisan politics . . . An evangelist is called to do one thing, and one thing only: to proclaim the gospel.”—Billy Graham, during an interview in the later years of his life
GW: All politics is not partisan. Graham could have been involved in politics without being so submissive to or supportive of the Republican Party, including Nixon.
BA: This is quite an admission for one of the most famous Christian preachers, who had spent time with many prominent people of this world, including 12 US Presidents. (See the article on this website entitled, “Learn One Thing From Billy Graham’s Life Confession”). This should at least give us pause when considering our own decision of whether to be involved in “partisan politics.
GW: Again, all politics is not partisan. You can take positions on what is best for the country without supporting a party.
BA: Billy Graham referred to the one thing a Christian is “called to do,” and that is what Jesus commanded: “Go and make disciples of all peoples” (Matthew 28:19 NLT margin).
GW: Unfortunately, the Christian message is wrong!
BA: He also referred to a Christian’s need for singleness of focus on spreading the gospel, which can be illustrated this way: “”Bear your share of difficulties, like a good soldier of Christ Jesus. No one on active service involves himself in the affairs of of civilian life, because he must win the approval of the man who enlisted him” (2 Timothy 2:3,4 NJB). Another Bible principle can also be applied here: “Jesus said, ‘No one who sets a hand to the plough and looks to what was left behind is fit for the kingdom of God” (Luke 9:62 NAB). To plow straight furrows in a field, one must keep focused on what is ahead, not behind. Political involvement could, at a minimum, cause a Christian to lose his/her focus on spreading the gospel.
GW: There is no good evidence for any “kingdom of God.” In fact, we now know that God does not exist. This has been proven. The “gospel” happens to be worthless. If God did exist, he would not forgive anyone for their sins. He would implement perfect justice. You worship a lesser god.
BA: For Christians, “All scripture is inspired by God and useful for refuting error, for guiding people’s lives and teaching them to be his people.
GW: There are a few useful principles presented in the Bible, but most of the verses are false. They are based on a false view of reality. God is not part of our reality.
BA: This is how someone who is dedicated to God becomes fully equipped and ready for every good work” (2 Timothy 3:16,17 NJB). Is it possible that Christian involvement in politics could be included as a type of “error” referred to in the scriptures?
GW: It is possible, but not likely. Jesus was involved in politics, just not partisan politics. Back in his day there were no political parties. However, he represented a new sect of Judaism, which eventually split off from Judaism.
BA: While there are no examples in the Bible of God’s people being involved in politics, there is no specific counsel to the contrary in the Bible either.
GW: Jesus preached patience, mostly pacifism, and an other-worldly focus with respect to the ruling Roman empire. This was in contrast to the Zealots.
BA: Therefore, we do well to consider what Bible principles may apply in such a situation, and make decisions based on those Bible principles. Are there any Bible principles that indicate that God may not want his people to be involved in partisan politics?
GW: Maybe, but probably not. In regard to taxation Jesus said “Give unto Caesar what is Caesar’s and give unto God what is God’s.” [paraphrased] He preached mainly a submission to the Roman empire. He thought it would soon end. He was wrong. In fact, the Romans destroyed Jerusalem within 40 years of Jesus’ death.
BA: Some Christians believe that it their duty to try to elect good people to political office so as to improve the world, and also to help facilitate the spread of the gospel.
GW: And they are correct on that first part. If I remember correctly, you don’t even vote. That is a serious dereliction of duty as a citizen of this country.
BA: However, Jesus’ direction to his followers seems to run counter to that idea: “Seek the Kingdom of God above all else and live righteously, and he will give you everything you need” (Matthew 6:33 NLT).
GW: Notice that he used the words “above all else.” He is not recommending to ignore politics.
BA: There is nothing wrong with government employment.
GW: Well, thank you for saying that. I worked for 23 years for the federal government.
BA: However, government employment is not the same thing as political involvement.
GW: Well, of course. I have done both.
BA: God’s people have worked for governments since ancient times. Examples of pre-Christians are Joseph, Mordecai, Nehemiah and Daniel, Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego (Genesis 41:41-43; Nehemiah 2:1; Esther 10:3; Daniel 2:48,49). Paul, apparently writing from the city of Corinth, concludes the book of Romans with greetings from some early Christians. “Erastus, the city treasurer, and our brother Quartus greet you” (Romans 16:23 NAB). Erastus was a Christian who was employed as “the city treasurer.”
GW: Erastus had a good job.
BA: The Bible tells us that, “Everyone must submit to governing authorities. For all authority comes from God, and those placed in positions of authority have been placed there by God” (Romans 13:1 NLT).
GW: False. If God did exist, he would oppose some governing authorities, like the Nazis, the Communists, and the Trumpists. He would oppose the murderous Vladimir Putin.
BA: The point here is that “all authority comes from God,” and “those placed in positions of authority have been placed there by God,” not humans.
GW: And the point is totally false! God would not put Hitler in a position of authority! What the heck are you talking about? You are opposing democracies and supporting monarchies! Shameful.
BA: There is no indication here, or elsewhere, that God wants us to help select those “placed in positions of authority” by him.
GW: So, you are recommending that people just not vote, like you. Preposterous!
BA: The book of Daniel makes clear that “the Most High God rules over the kingdoms of this world and appoints anyone he wishes to rule over them,” and “he controls the course of world events; he removes kings and sets up kings” (Daniel 5:21; 2:21 NLT).
GW: God does not exist, but even if he did, he would not appoint the leaders of nations. The book of Daniel is just mistaken.
BA: The Bible also tells us that, “From one man he created all the nations throughout the whole earth.
GW: False again! It is biologically impossible to produce the entire human species through just one man.
BA: He decided beforehand when they should rise and fall, and he determined their boundaries” (Acts 17:26 NLT).
GW: Here you are advocating THEISTIC DETERMINISM. Are you a Calvinist?
BA: Since he “has perfect knowledge” (Job 36:4 NIV), and is “Almighty” (Job 37:23), we can trust his decisions and judgments to always be perfectly right.
GW: God is not an anybody to trust. He does not exist. If a god proclaimed that he was God, we’d still have to interrogate and test him to confirm his claim. Ponder how that could be done.
BA: Since “God controls the course of world events,” and has ‘decided in advance when nations and leaders should rise and fall,’ there is really nothing we can do to change that.
GW: So, you are implying that if God did exist, then he would have allowed the Holocaust perpetrated by Hitler. Of maybe you even think that God CAUSED the Holocaust. Please defend these crazy ideas. For the opposing view (the fact of the matter), see my Holocaust argument.
BA: These Bible principles certainly do not mean that those in political power always do the right things. They don’t. The governments are run by sinful people, (Romans 3:23), who make mistakes, and some are even “corrupt” (Psalm 14:1 NIV).
GW: But your god approves of this? Allows it? Causes it? You aren’t making any sense.
BA: “Satan, the ruler of this world” (John 12:31 NIV) is shown in the Bible to have much influence over the governments of the world. When he “showed [Jesus] all the kingdoms of the world” and said, “all this power . . . has been handed over to me, and I may give it to whomever I wish” (Luke 4:5,6 NAB), Jesus did not contradict his claim, but he flatly rejected Satan’s suggestion to worship him in exchange for rulership over them. Keeping these facts and principles in mind will help us to realize that we will not be able to change this world.
GW: Facts? There are no facts here! If God did exist, he would not allow Satan to exist. And so, we can tell from this passage alone that Jesus was not divine or even a messenger of God. He couldn’t have been since he was entirely mistaken about Satan.
BA: Jesus said that his disciples “do not belong to the world any more than I belong to the world” (John 17:14,16 NAB, NJB). Jesus further emphasized this principle by saying, “The world would love you as its own if you belonged to it, but you are no longer part of the world. I chose you to come out of the world, so it hates you” (John 15:19 NLT). Christians are told that, “Religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father is this: . . . to keep oneself unstained by the world” (James 1:27 NAB).
GW: Nonsense. They were all human beings living on the Earth.
BA: These directives, combined with other Biblical statements, can be seen as Christians being advised to avoid partisan politics. Political neutrality is another way to express such an idea.
GW: Maybe partisan politics, but not politics in general.
BA: Did Jesus ever involve himself in any politics of this world? No, he didn’t!
GW: Of course he did. He involved himself in politics advocating submission to the Roman empire and waiting patiently for a new kingdom, at least until his last week on Earth. Then he openly challenged the Romans in Jerusalem.
BA: “When the people saw the sign he had done [miraculously feeding thousands], they said, ‘This is truly the Prophet, the one who is to come into the world.’
GW: Nope. There is no good evidence that any miracle has ever happened in the history of humankind! It is more likely that people lie or make mistakes in perception or interpretation than that a miracle occurs. Scottish philosopher David Hume wrote a great deal about this.
BA: Since Jesus knew that they were going to come and carry him off to make him king, he withdrew into the mountain alone” (John 6:14,15 NAB). He refused to be drafted into politics as a leader.
GW: He was a leader, just a different kind of leader than the Jews were familiar with.
BA: The Bible tells us that “Christ . . . left an example for you to follow in his steps” (1 Peter 2:21 NJB). If the greatest man who ever lived avoided political involvement, perhaps we should too.
GW: But Jesus did not avoid political involvement. He modeled a certain kind of political behavior.
BA: Did Jesus ever make any political comments, or give any political opinions? No! He was asked, “Is it permissible to pay taxes to Caesar or not? . . . Jesus . . . replied, ‘. . . Show me the money you pay the tax with.’ They handed him a denarius, and he said, ‘Choose portrait is this? Whose title?’ They replied, ‘Caesar’s.’ Then he said to them, ‘Very well, pay Caesar what belongs to Caesar–and God what belongs to God'” (Matthew 22:17-21 NJB). Jesus did not express any opinion one way or the other about paying taxes to the Roman government, other than to say, ‘If you owe the tax, pay it.’
GW: Here you contradict yourself. Jesus recommended that people pay their taxes to the Roman empire. That is a political statement.
BA: Did the early Christians involve themselves in any politics of their day? No! So, because of this, they were viewed with suspicion.
GW: Of course they did!
BA: For example, it was said of them, “They are all guilty of treason against Caesar, for they profess allegiance to another king, named Jesus” (Acts 17:17 NLT).
GW: There you go. The verse proves my point. Professing allegiance to another king is a political statement. Duh.
BA: Paul, Silas and other Christians were not advocating rebellion against the Roman government, but their loyalty to another king sounded suspicious. Early Christians were known for their non-involvement in politics.
GW: I have already falsified this idea. Jesus was politically active, just in a different way from most, especially the Zealots.
BA: Strict application of Bible principles by Christians today often results in misunderstandings.
GW: Strict application of Bible statements by anyone today is morally wrong and harmful.
BA: Another aspect to consider is that all nations are eventually doomed to destruction from God.
GW: False. God does not exist and thus he has nothing to do with the future of humanity.
BA: “All the kings of the earth and their armies” will be gathered together to fight” against Jesus and his army” during “the war of the Great Day of God the Almighty” (Revelation 16:14; 19:19-21 NJB).
GW: Nonsense. Jesus is dead and will remain so. There is no good evidence that any person has EVER come back to life. Jesus won’t.
BA: Why put forth so much effort into something that God is going to destroy?
GW: If you believe this silly idea, then why do you preach that human beings should work to reduce global warming? Why strive to save the habitat of the Earth when you think God is going to destroy the Earth anyway? You are actually contradicting yourself.
BA: Sometimes people misunderstand those Christians who are politically neutral, and they think that their message is to get everyone in the world to stay out of politics. They raise objections, such as: ‘If everyone avoided politics, who will run the world?’
GW: If everyone avoided politics, nobody ran for office or nobody voted, yes, who would run the world? The dictators. The most powerful. Is that the kind of world in which you wish to live? You are speaking pure nonsense. All citizens should participate in politics! It’s your moral duty.
BA: We can learn a lesson from Jesus’ statement concerning a different issue: “Jesus told him, ‘Let the spiritually dead bury their own dead! Your duty is go and preach about the kingdom of God'” (Luke 9:60 NLT). One point we can glean from this is that there will always be plenty of people who will ‘run the world’ by being in political power.
GW: Well, if the Christians stay out of politics, then in one way that would be good thing since the Christians are the ones who enabled Donald Trump to become president. If they sit on the sidelines, then it will be a landslide for Joe Biden in 2024. I am fine if the Christians sit out for the 2024 presidential election.
Jesus was not “involved in politics”, as you assert, rather he avoided politics, as evidenced by his getting away from those who wanted to draft him into political involvement (John 6:14,15).
False. Jesus was involved in politics, as I already demonstrated.
Why do you waste time on these peripheral issues? Christianity rests on two fundamental ideas — 1) God exists, and 2) Jesus came back to life. Since the first is definitely false and the second is very likely false, continued belief in Christianity is fruitless and irrational.